This Traeger Tomahawk Ribeye is one of the shining stars of the steak world, but one that can be intimidating, especially for those new to bbq. Don’t let it be. This cowboy steak is simple to make, and will be the star of your next cookout! Get yourself a bone-in ribeye today!

Tomahawk Ribeye

Are you looking for a steak that’ll make people say, “WHOA”? 

You totally found it. 

The next time you are reaching for a delicious steak option, seek out this trendy cut and fire up the grill. You’re about to wow people. 

What is a tomahawk ribeye?

The Tomahawk ribeye, also known as a cowboy steak or bone-in ribeye, is a popular cut of steak that leaves a large, long, bone attached to the classic ribeye cut. 

Cooking meat on the bone gives it more flavor, and you can’t beat the presentation of this impressive steak.

Don’t be intimidated by how large it is. I’m going to give you a foolproof way to make sure your steak is perfectly cooked, amazingly tender, and the perfect temperature. 

More Easy Traeger Recipes here!

Why cook steak at home?

I love cooking steak at home because SO MANY restaurants do it wrong. Also, I hate ordering things out that I could make BETTER at home and without a ton of effort. 

Homemade pasta? Yeah, I could probably match most restaurants when it comes to a great homemade noodle, but holy crap that is a lot of labor involved. Like, say goodbye to your afternoon. I don’t feel bad at all about ordering that in a restaurant. 

That’s also one of the reasons I eat Ramen so much when I’m traveling or just going out to dinner. I can totally cook it at home. But it takes 4 days to get to the actual final result, and I have to seriously gear myself up.

There is also the COST factor.

Restaurant tomahawk ribeyes are even more marked up than your average steak, and unless you are eating at WAY fancier restaurants than I am (entirely possible), you aren’t even getting a higher grade of meat. 

More great BEEF recipes here!

How much is the tomahawk ribeye at Outback?

Well, first of all, I couldn’t even FIND a tomahawk steak on the menu at Outback. I did find a bone-in ribeye, but that’s not necessarily the same thing. A Tomahawk ribeye needs to have at least 5 inches of bone still attached and are also typically thicker than bone-in ribeye.

If you want to classify it in that category, you can pick one up for around $35 at Outback. So get that bloomin’ onion too while you’re at it. 

Not the most expensive steak you’ll ever order, but it also won’t be nearly as good as if you had cooked it at home.

Buy Pellets here!

How much is a tomahawk steak at Ruth Chris?

If you are going fancy tonight and are considering grabbing up a tender tomahawk steak at Ruth Chris? Prepare your wallet cause one of these will set you back almost $120. 

Yeah. 

You read that right. 

If you want the photo opp, why not do it in the comfort of your own home?

Follow me on Instagram!

Where can I buy a tomahawk ribeye?

You should be able to find a good tomahawk at your local butcher shop. If you typically shop at regular grocery stores for your meat, try requesting these specifically if they don’t have them out on the shelves.

I’ve also found tomahawk ribeyes at Costco and my local small grocer as well, so keep your eyes open!

24 Incredible Traeger Recipes

How to cook a Tomahawk Ribeye

The best way to cook any steak is always going to be over live fire, in my book. There is something about that smoke and fire that does amazing things to beef, in particular, so you’ll never convince me that a griddle or pan-fried steak is as good as a steak cooked over live fire. 

Join our Easy Traeger Recipes Facebook Group!

What other ways can you cook a tomahawk ribeye?

That being said, if you don’t have live fire available, a cast-iron steak is better than no steak, so fire it up and get cooking no matter what method you choose. 

How to grill a tomahawk ribeye?

Grilling a tomahawk is simple. You just need to prepare because to do it properly, it takes a while. My favorite method for cooking at tomahawk is on the grill, using the reverse sear method. 

Reverse Seared Tomahawk Ribeye

Reverse searing is a method where you slow smoke the steak at a low temperature for a long time. Once it reaches the temperate you’d like (typically 125° for medium-rare, the only way you should be eating steak), you pull it off the grill and sear it on a very hot cast iron pan, Blackstone Griddle, or right back on your pellet grill. 

It gets a quick sear to brown both sides and then rests before serving. 

What’s the difference between a tomahawk ribeye and a cowboy steak?

Nothing. 

They are the same thing, just with different titles. You can call it anything you want, as long as it is also called delicious.

I’m not sure either of them is particularly p.c. if you are worried about that sort of thing, but use your own judgment there. 

What should I serve with a tomahawk ribeye?

Steak and potatoes is a perfect match, so for starters, I’d suggest getting some baby potatoes and doing a batch of Smoked Smashed Potatoes. Another great option would be our Smoked Potato Stacks.

Next, you need a vegetable, so get going on these Perfect Grilled Asparagus. It is simple, delicious, and always a hit.