Salted Caramel Spiked Apple Cider

Salted Spiked Caramel Apple Cider

I've been "testing" this cocktail all week long. Maybe for two weeks.

I'm normally not a whiskey drinker, but when I saw Salted Caramel Crown Royal at the store one fall I snatched it up like it was the last box of Count Chocula for the next year. If you can't find that particular bottle, there are several other salted caramel and caramel apple whiskeys that have popped up over the years, more on those options below.

The only time whiskey and I are really friends is in the winter months at band practice, when I like to sip hot apple cider (usually the packet kind, I'm not fancy) with a healthy dose of whiskey in there. For the vocal cords, of course. Purely for the craft, you know.

I love caramel apple everything. My apple crumble pie always gets a heavy drizzle of caramel on top of the scoop of French vanilla ice cream that has to go with it. I even make caramel myself sometimes, the really old-fashioned way with white sugar. That is no joke. Maybe it isn't even caramel and apple I love so much, just caramel itself. It shows up here a lot, is all I'm saying.

Why You'll Love This Recipe

• Five-minute cocktail. Heat, pour, top with whipped cream, done.
• Big holiday flavor. Salted caramel whiskey and apple cider were made for each other.
• That whipped cream. It's what takes this drink from good to "I already texted the recipe to three people."
• Easy to batch. Scales up perfectly for a crowd, see the party version below.
• Flexible. Swap the whiskey, skip the booze, adjust the sweetness, it all still works.

Choosing The Best Apple Cider For This Cocktail

Skip the powdered spiced cider mix packet for this one. It has its place, but for something special, you want the real thing.

Go buy a bottle of this year's unfiltered apple cider, or your favorite variety. Honeycrisp cider is my top pick when I can find it, it's got a natural sweetness and depth that holds up beautifully once you add whiskey and caramel into the mix. Major "you have your life together" fall bonus points if you bring home cider from an actual orchard.

How To Make Alcoholic Hot Apple Cider

This is the quick overview. Scroll down to the recipe card for exact amounts.

1. Whip the cream. Beat the whipped cream ingredients until stiff peaks form.
2. Heat the cider and whiskey. Warm them together on the stovetop or in the microwave, whichever is easiest.
3. Pour and top. Divide between mugs, add a big scoop of whipped cream, and garnish.

Apple Cider and Crown Royal: Why It Works

Salted Caramel Crown Royal is the whiskey that started this whole recipe for me. Regular Crown Royal works fine if you're not into flavored whiskey, but the Salted Caramel Apple version is a completely different experience, sweet, a little salty, and it plays perfectly against the tartness of the cider. I keep a bottle in reserve every year since it tends to be a seasonal release and can be hit or miss to find.

Other Ways To Spike Your Cider

Crown Royal isn't the only option here, so don't stress if your store is out. A few whiskey brands to look for: Fireball for a spicier kick, Jack Daniel's Fire, or any caramel or apple pie flavored whiskey your local shop carries.

Whiskey isn't even required. A few other spirits work really well with apple cider and caramel:

• Bourbon - adds a deeper, more traditional cocktail flavor and pairs beautifully with the caramel.
• Spiced or dark rum - leans into the warm spice notes already in the cider.
• Brandy or apple brandy - doubles down on the apple flavor for something a little more sophisticated.
• Caramel or butterscotch liqueur - stir a splash in alongside a plainer whiskey or rum if you want even more caramel flavor without switching your whole bottle.

If you want to build out a full lineup of winter cocktails alongside this one, my Holiday Wine Spritzer, Rumberry Punch, and Homemade Kahlua all fit the same cozy, boozy vibe.

Cinnamon Whipped Cream

This part is what takes the drink from "oh, that's good" to "whoa, I need to make this for everyone I know."

For 4 drinks, whip one cup of heavy whipping cream with ½ teaspoon ground cinnamon, 2-3 tablespoons powdered sugar, and a dash of vanilla extract. Whip it until it forms stiff peaks and holds its shape, you don't want it melting straight into the hot cider the second it hits the mug.

A few variations worth trying:

• Maple whipped cream - swap the powdered sugar for a tablespoon of maple syrup.
• Extra cinnamon - if you love a stronger spice flavor, bump it up to a full teaspoon.
• Brown sugar swap - powdered sugar keeps the texture the smoothest, but a tablespoon of brown sugar adds a deeper, more caramel-forward sweetness if you want to lean into that flavor even more.
• Vanilla bean - scrape a little vanilla bean paste in instead of extract for an extra fancy touch.

Heavy whipping cream is non-negotiable here, it's what gives you those stiff, scoopable peaks. Regular whipping cream or half and half won't hold up the same way.

Garnish Ideas

A sprinkle of cinnamon and a drizzle of caramel sauce over the whipped cream is the easiest finishing touch, and it makes the drink look like something out of a coffee shop. Dried apple slices or a fresh apple slice fanned out on the rim add a nice bit of presentation without any extra work. If you want to go further, a caramel drizzle around the inside rim of the mug before you pour the cider in gives you that pretty striped look every time someone takes a sip.

Batching This For A Party

This recipe scales up really easily for a crowd. Multiply the cider and whiskey by your headcount, keeping the same 16-24 ounces of cider per 6 ounces of whiskey ratio, and warm the whole batch together in a large pot on the stove or in a slow cooker set to low. The slow cooker is actually my favorite way to do this for a party, since it keeps the cider warm for hours without anyone needing to babysit it.

Make the whipped cream separately, right before your guests arrive, and set out a little garnish station with cinnamon, caramel sauce, and apple slices so everyone can top their own mug.

Serve This With

This cocktail is basically a dessert on its own, so it pairs best with something to actually eat alongside it.

Try it with my Apple Crumble Pie for a double dose of caramel apple, or my Fresh Apple Crisp if you want something a little less rich.

It's also a great match for a big holiday spread, I usually have a mug going while the Traeger Smoked Turkey rests before carving.

Pin For Later